
A Dog's Perfect Christmas — Good Boy, Thin Script
Rating: 2.5/5 · English · Holiday family drama · Netflix, streaming from 4 November 2026 · Director: Cathryn Michon · Cast: Dennis Quaid, Milo Ventimiglia, Brooke Lena Johnson, Mary Steenburgen, Jennifer Tilly, Ethan Loomis; Thomas Haden Church voices Winstead
The third film in the A Dog's Purpose family drops the reincarnation angle, and, as every review rushes to reassure you, the dog lives. What remains is a glossy, cosy Netflix Christmas movie with a surprisingly grim setup and an overqualified cast.
Grieving widower Sander (Dennis Quaid) has sunk into selfish sadness. His son Hunter (Milo Ventimiglia) works too hard, and his granddaughter Ello (Brooke Lena Johnson) is a reluctant scholarship winner. When the mother of the family falls seriously ill and ends up in a coma, everyone is forced to step up. Narrating it all is Sander's basset hound Winstead, who senses the family's feelings without grasping the details.
Quaid is the main reason to watch. He seems genuinely invested for the first time in a while: funny, romantic and convincing as a man finally rejoining his family. His dalliances with Jennifer Tilly's brash Lucille and Mary Steenburgen's warm Claire add welcome lightness. The film's best scene is an unbroken take of Ello and her boyfriend ice-dancing, showing off the actors' real skating skills and real chemistry.
Elsewhere it is thin. Winstead's narration is neither funny nor insightful, and the dogs, including a new puppy who is supposed to save the family, barely affect the plot. The tone swings oddly between grief, illness and fluffy holiday comfort, and the family's problems rarely feel lived-in. Critics landed between "wholesome but threadbare" and outright dismissive.
Verdict: A pleasant background watch for dog lovers and Quaid fans during the holidays. Do not expect it to linger the way A Dog's Purpose did.
Critical reception drawn from: TheWrap, What's on Netflix,